natekinkead

This simple yet powerful plugin integrates with the bbPress forum plugin to add a new feature which allows users or visitors to vote up or down on topics and replies. Each topic and reply has a total score with an up arrow and a down arrow.
This plugin uses AJAX to save the vote on-the-fly without refreshing the page.
It’s also AMP compatible!
Visitors can only vote once on each topic or reply.
Features Included: 
* Show or hide (and customize) labels for up and down 
* Disable voting on topics or replies globally 
* Disable voting on specific forums 
* View-only score on closed topics 
* Sort topics and replies by voting scores 
* Admin bypass 
* GamiPress integration
Pro Features Available: 
* Historical weighted score visualization 
* Accepted answers 
* “Who voted” avatars 
* Sort dropdown 
* Sort on weighted score 
* Sort on trending score 
* Trending topics widget 
* Schema for Q&A rich snippets 
* Voting email notification to author 
* Mark topics or replies with poor scores as spam
Purchase bbPress Voting Pro at <a href="https://wpforthewin.com/product/bbpress-voting-pro/" rel="nofollow ugc">WP For The Win</a>!

bbPress Voting

I hope you enjoy this plugin!  If you have any questions, please post a topic in the for support forum.

Couldn't believe there was nothing out there like this!

Although I wish it had some options for placement. Not sure I like it above the author avatar.

Pretty cool

Let visitors vote up and down on bbPress topics and replies just like Reddit or Stack Overflow!

webefficient

WP Emoticon Rating is wordress plugin which allows your visitors to rate your posts and pages., 
visitors can express their rating in the form of emoticons, very easy to use,Just install and activate the plugin and set global the settings to use, 
It is very eye catching display of emoticons bellow your posts and pages.
A few notes about the sections above:
We are glad to hear from you. We would love to provide service for your wordpress site.

WP Emoticon Rating

Allow Your visitors to express what they feel about your posts and pages

bbPress Voting vs WP Emoticon Rating