Ashish Kumar (Ashfame)

Plugin offers a admin screen to select the posts of which commentators should be emailed, and then you can write the subject & message to send and the plugin will send them an email along with their comment history on the selected posts.
You also have the option of excluding list of emails and specifying a Bcc email address.
If you find a bug, please report the issue here – https://github.com/ashfame/email-posts-commentators/issues

Email Posts Commentators

Beherit

Sends an simply email notification to the comment author, when someone replies to his comment. No configuration, support WordPress translation process.

Simple Comment Notification

Sends an simply email notification to the comment author, when someone replies to his comment.

Email Posts Commentators vs Simple Comment Notification