fsquared

The F2 Tumblr Widget displays recent posts from the provided tumblr blog.
It allows the user to select how many posts to display, to restrict which 
posts are shown by type and tag, and to render the posts as either a list 
or a slideshow.
Posts can be displayed in full, as title only, or with an excerpt. Photo, 
video and audio posts will have the media displayed when the display type 
is not ‘title only’.
The audio player in posts can now be automatically resized to match the 
selected media width – this is enabled by default, but can be deselected 
in the widget setup.

F2 Tumblr Widget

This widget displays recent posts from a tumblr blog.

Pixelpillow

Create posts based on content type in a Tumblr like way. We’ve included a set of default icons for most thinkable content types, or just add your own custom content types with your own icons. The icons are also shown in the post overview for optimal visual distinction between posts.
We recommend using the Advance Custom Fields plugin to create custom field per content type

Custom Content Types by Pixelpillow

Create posts based on content type in a Tumblr like way. Add your own custom content types with your own icons that also shown in the post overview.

F2 Tumblr Widget vs Custom Content Types by Pixelpillow