edward_plainview

When entering a comment the plugin will load some Javascript values – unique for the visitor – to ensure that the user is a real person.
If Javascript is not enabled in the visitor’s browser, an error message will be shown when submitting the comment.
The spam protection is not enabled for logged-in users.

Plainview Comment Antispam

Prevent comment spam automatically by using Javascript.

OneOfOne

This plugin plugin blocks spam in comments automatically, without requiring any end-user input or any javascript.
<ul>
<li>As of version 0.7.7 there’s an option to add an extra javascript check, it’s off by default.</li>
</ul>
In a way it’s similar to webvitaly’s <a href="https://wordpress.org/plugins/anti-spam/" rel="ugc">Anti-Spam</a> however this doesn’t require the user to enter anything at all.
The comment gets marked as spam if any of the following rules are true :
<ul>
<li>If the comment is a trackback.</li>
<li>If the time between loading the page and commenting is less than 10 seconds.</li>
<li>If the Session variable specific to this form is not set.</li>
<li>If the hidden input field have a different value than “-“.</li>
<li>If the comment includes more than 3 urls.</li>
<li>If the referer isn’t set properly.</li>
</ul>
Once the comment gets flagged as spam, and if the auto delete option isn’t set, a json string will be appended to it to show why it was marked, for example :
<pre><code>{ "is-trackback": 0, "no-session-token": 0, "hidden-field": 1, "number-of-urls": 5, "referer": 0, "too-fast": 1.902538061142 } </code></pre>
Translates to :
<ol>
<li>They changed the hidden input field.</li>
<li>They Had 5 URLs in the comment.</li>
<li>It Took 1.9 seconds to submit the comment since the page was loaded.</li>
</ol>
Also note that the time calculations are per-form, so there are no false-positives if the user has multiple pages open on the site and commented on 2 of them in a short period of time.
Feel free to fork it and submit patches / fixes on <a href="https://github.com/OneOfOne/ooo-nospam" rel="nofollow ugc">github</a>

OneOfOne’s NoSpam

Extremely simple, 0 configuration and 0 user/admin-interaction anti-spam plugin.

Plainview Comment Antispam vs OneOfOne’s NoSpam