Diana K. Cury

Very simple pluing, no configs, no screens, just action! 
Simple Smilies add all WordPress smillies in comments form and a simple javascript let users click them to insert. 
This is a very light plugin, the javascript only loads when in singular/single contexts, also there is no stylesheets.

Simple Smilies

Let users insert WordPress smilies when commenting in you site.

Samuel Wood (Otto)

Replace the smilies with the original versions from previous versions of WordPress.
Added bonus: Disables all “emoji” functionality in WordPress 4.2 and above.

Classic Smilies

I have been using this plugin and I proudly recommend to everyone.
PRO
- It improve performance by removing inline JS and reducing HTTP requests.
Cons
- Smiley images shouldn't be look dull. It could be appear clear like Original.

Thanks & Regards,
Gulshan

Very goood plugin, some improvement needed

Replace the smilies with the original versions from previous versions of WordPress.

Simple Smilies vs Classic Smilies