flocsy

Title Icon plugin
Displays a small icon or smiley in the title. You have to add <code><?php if (function_exists('the_title_icon')) the_title_icon(); ?></code> to your index.php, single.php, page.php, archive.php 
before or after the <code><?php the_title(); ?></code>
Title Icon plugin works together with:
<ul>
<li>LMB^Box Smileys plugin (http://aboutme.lmbbox.com/lmbbox-plugins/lmbbox-smileys/)</li>
<li>Smilies Themer plugin (http://rick.jinlabs.com/code/smilies-themer/)</li>
</ul>

Title Icon

Title Icon plugin displays a small icon or smiley in the title.

themifyme

Insert the Themify Icons easily in your post content, WordPress menus, and widget titles.

Themify Icons

Nifty plugin that enables you to use the Themify Icons (https://themify.me/themify-icons) font on your site.

Title Icon vs Themify Icons