Archetyped

Favicon Rotator makes it easy to customize the favicon for your site. Just add a favicon via the administration page and it will be displayed whenever someone visits your site.
<h4>Highlights</h4>
<ul>
<li>New: Set icon for Touch devices (Android, iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch, etc.)</li>
<li>Simply point and click to add a favicon to your site</li>
<li>Supports adding multiple icons, from which a randomly selected favicon will be displayed.</li>
<li>Automatic icon conversion for large images (smaller files and faster loading)</li>
</ul>
<h4>Usage</h4>
<ol>
<li>Go to Theme > Favicon admin page to add/upload image(s) to use for the favicon</li>
</ol>
That’s it! The favicon will be displayed in visitors’ browsers when they visit your site
Notes
<ul>
<li>Verify that your theme uses the <code>wp_head()</code> template tag</li>
<li>If you add multiple icons, then a randomly selected icon will be displayed each time the site is loaded</li>
</ul>
<a href="http://archetyped.com/tools/favicon-rotator/" rel="nofollow ugc">More Information on Favicon Rotator’s Official Page</a>

Favicon Rotator

Easily set site favicon and even rotate through multiple icons

epipe-com

This plugin adds a favicon link to the document head section.
There are no options. The link is always added when the plugin is enabled.
The <code>favicon.ico</code> file needs to be uploaded to the site’s root 
directory. If you do not know how to do this, you should have a look at 
one of the other favicon plugins.

The Simplest Favicon

Adds a favicon link to the document head section.

Favicon Rotator vs The Simplest Favicon